Book Review

Book Review: The Winters, by Lisa Gabriele (2018)

I’m going to be honest from the outset and say that I wasn’t totally enamoured by this book. It was pacy, and full of dark twists, but certain things frustrated me about it. Lots of readers will enjoy it, though, so I’ll keep this review as balanced as possible – I am just one reader, after all.

The premise

A young woman working in the Cayman islands is suddenly swept off her feet when Max Winter, a wealthy senator and recent widower – arrives at the boating resort she works at. She falls head over heels for him, opting to leave her life of drudgery behind for the grandeur of Asherley, Max’s mansion on his private island in The Hamptons.

When she arrives, though, it’s clear that the memory of the first Mrs Winter – the glamorous Rebekah – is very much a presence in the house, kept alive by Dani, the Winters’ rebellious teenage daughter.

Slowly, the young bride-to-be is drawn into the family’s deepest and darkest secrets, and is forced to choose exactly where her loyalties lie.


My review

If any of the above sounds familiar, you’ve probably read Daphne du Maurier’s novel, Rebecca, from which Lisa Gabriele has taken inspiration for her own novel.

I think this may have been the biggest obstacle to my truly enjoying this book. Though there are some overt changes – replacing the primary setting, altering some character roles, and adapting some aspects of the plot – The Winters felt too close to du Maurier’s book to me. I often really enjoy books that adapt elements of popular novels, using the authors imagination and unique style to interpret a story in new ways. Rebecca itself has close links to Charlotte Brontë’s Jane Eyre. I just think my appreciation of Rebecca was always at the fore whilst I was reading, and in The Winters, the parallels felt too obvious. For many readers, this won’t be a bother, or even noticeable if they’ve not read du Maurier’s novel. It just affected my own reading, often taking away the suspense within the story.

Characters also appeared to lack nuance: they don’t need to be likeable for me to enjoy a book, it’s more that I want to believe their role and motivation within the context of the story being told. I couldn’t fully get that here, though there were moments when I could have done if certain aspects had been explored further.

That being said, there were elements that I enjoyed and that would appeal to so many readers. For a start, it’s got a really quick pace, which gives it that page-turning quality. There are lots of twists within it, and some moments of genuine tension where I honestly didn’t know which direction that story would take. The isolation of Asherley on its island provided added to that, increasing the stakes when the narrator felt ill at ease. I also really liked how the apparent glamour and excess of the Winters’ wealth opposed that sense of chilling isolation.

Certain story strands that were unique to this book were intriguing, particularly where they concerned Dani Winter’s character. In my opinion, she was easily the most compelling figure in this book, and if aspects of her story had been developed more, it could have really lifted my enjoyment of the entire narrative.


So while this book wasn’t the right one for me, if you’re a fan of pacy, dark, sinister tales, it would be worth giving this a read. The glamour of extreme wealth in The Hamptons provides a pretty unsettling backdrop to this sinister story of betrayal.


Thanks for reading my review. To see who else has featured on the blog tour, check out the poster below:

The Winters FINAL Blog Tour Poster.png


*The Winters, written by Lisa Gabriele, was published by Harvill Secker, an imprint of Vintage, Penguin Random House, and by Viking in the USA, in 2018.

** Thank you to the team at Vintage for sending a copy of The Winters in exchange for an honest review as part of the publication blog tour

7 thoughts on “Book Review: The Winters, by Lisa Gabriele (2018)”

    1. Thank you. It was definitely too close to the original for me, but from other reviews I’ve read, it’s not been as noticeable/bothersome to those readers. I’m just very attached to du Maurier haha!

  1. The cover is really nice, but I’m probably also not the one who’d enjoy the book. Thank you for your honest opinion 😁 It sounds like such a classic phrase but I really mean it.

    1. Thank you, that’s lovely of you to say. I was nervous about posting this review because it’s been the first one I’ve not totally enjoyed for a while. But I always appreciate when bloggers are honest in reviews so I wanted to do the same.

      1. I’m quite new to blogging. Before I started blogging I didn’t even know that negative reviews can be a topic for a discussion. It’s been always obvious to me that review is a review, it should review an object, not just praise it no matter what. When I realised not all reviewers share my opinion I started being very careful about whose reviews I trust. So I am always very thankful when a blogger posts exactly what she thinks. I trust all other reviews of this blogger then too. So, thanks one more time!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s